UP SIR : Bulk Forms 7 Filed Were Fake, Not Acted Upon, Says ECI; Supreme Court Directs Corrective Steps

By Sangeeta Sharma

New Delhi, Oct 30 (LAB): The Election Commission of India (ECI) on Thursday informed the Supreme Court that bulk Form 7 applications allegedly submitted during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Uttar Pradesh were found to be false and no action had been taken on them.

The Supreme Court directed the ECI to examine any remaining complaints, take necessary corrective steps and file a compliance report.

A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India (CJI) Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana was hearing an application in petitions challenging the SIR exercise in Uttar Pradesh. The petitioners include Congress MP Tanuj Punia and Samajwadi Party leader Arvind Kumar Singh.

During the hearing, counsel for the applicant pointed out that the ECI had been directed on August 5 to file its response within two weeks. Senior Advocate Dama Seshadri Naidu, appearing for the ECI, informed the court that a counter-affidavit had been filed.

Naidu submitted that the complaints regarding bulk filing of Form 7 applications had been examined by election officials. After verification and cross-checking, the forms were found to be false and had not been acted upon.

However, counsel for the applicant questioned the ECI’s claim and sought judicial scrutiny of the allegations. He submitted that 32 Form 7 applications had been filed in one constituency against voters belonging to a particular community. Of these, two applications were allegedly signed by Booth Level Officers (BLOs).

He further alleged that the authorities had failed to take corrective action during the UP SIR exercise, which had encouraged similar incidents in Karnataka and Telangana, where the Chief Electoral Officer had directed the registration of FIRs over bulk filing of Form 7 applications.

Taking note of the submissions, the CJI asked the petitioner’s counsel to provide the ECI with details of any remaining complaints.

The Bench directed the ECI to examine the factual aspects of the complaints, make necessary corrections and submit a compliance report.

The court recorded in its order that the petitioner’s counsel had brought certain additional irregularities to its notice and would hand over a note containing the details to the senior counsel appearing for the ECI.

Supreme Court considers complaints relating to Kerala SIR

During the hearing, the court also considered petitions challenging the SIR exercise in Kerala and Chhattisgarh.

With regard to Kerala, Naidu submitted that the SIR process had been completed and elections had also been held after the exercise. He argued that the matter had become infructuous.

A counsel appearing for the petitioners sought an extension of time, stating that the verification period was due to end that day. The counsel also pointed out that around 24 lakh people were still outside the verification process.

The CJI observed that although the ECI had completed the exercise, the process of correcting electoral rolls was continuing and eligible voters who had been left out could still approach the authorities.

The court asked the petitioners to provide details of such persons to the ECI through representations and directed the Commission to consider their cases sympathetically and submit a report.

The order stated that several persons had allegedly been unable to submit their enumeration forms due to shortage of time. The petitioners were permitted to furnish their details to the ECI for consideration.

The CJI observed that there was no need to extend the deadline separately, as correction and inclusion in electoral rolls remained a continuing process.

ECI gets four weeks to respond on Chhattisgarh SIR

Regarding Chhattisgarh, the petitioners pointed out that the ECI had not filed its counter-affidavit despite notice having been issued in December.

Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran, appearing for the petitioners, argued that the Commission could not seek to treat the matter as infructuous merely because the SIR exercise had been completed.

He submitted that large-scale deletions had taken place and that the petitioners were also placing a detailed note before the court. He requested the ECI to file a comprehensive affidavit addressing the allegations.

The Supreme Court granted the ECI four weeks to file its counter-affidavit and respond to the note submitted by the petitioners./ LAB/ SNG