By Sangeeta Sharma
New Delhi, Oct 30 (LAB) The Supreme Court has observed that it is not the court’s responsibility to pass moral judgments on the personal relationship choices made by adults. It said that even if such choices lead to undesirable or hurtful consequences, they cannot automatically be treated as criminal offences requiring State intervention.
A Bench of Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan made these observations while quashing criminal proceedings against a man accused of rape on the false promise of marriage, cheating and bigamy.
The case arose from a woman’s allegation that the man had concealed his existing marriage and children, presented himself as a bachelor and married her.
The Court observed that adult men and women are free to make their own decisions, whether wise or unwise, prudent or reckless. Such decisions may have unexpected or painful consequences, but that alone does not make them criminal offences.
The Bench cautioned that criminal law should not be used as a weapon to settle personal scores, take revenge or force an individual to act in a particular manner.
Examining the facts of the case, the Court noted that the woman came to know within six months of the relationship that the man was already married and had children. Despite this knowledge, she continued to live with him for nearly seven years.
According to the Court, this conduct weakened her claim that she continued to believe that she was his legally wedded wife.
The Bench concluded that the relationship and the physical intimacy between the two were consensual and that the man had subsequently decided to end the relationship. His decision to withdraw from the relationship could not, by itself, lead to an inference of rape under Section 376(2)(n) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), the Court held.
Concern over consensual relationships turning into criminal cases
The Supreme Court expressed concern over what it described as an increasing trend of failed consensual relationships being converted into criminal proceedings.
The judgment observed that such disputes often end in settlements involving substantial monetary payments by the male accused.
The Court said it was unfortunate that despite repeated judicial warnings, this trend continued to increase and remained a matter of concern.
Consent based on belief in marriage must be examined
At the same time, the Bench made it clear that its observations should not be understood as reducing the seriousness of genuine allegations of rape and sexual assault.
It acknowledged that rape remains heavily underreported and that genuine cases must be pursued vigorously whenever the facts establish sexual assault or violence.
The Court also recognised that in Indian society, where marriage has significant social and cultural importance, a woman may agree to physical intimacy because she believes that the relationship is based on a legally recognised marriage or is intended to lead to such a marriage.
In such circumstances, marriage may form the very basis of her decision to enter into a sexual relationship, making her consent conditional on the belief that the marriage is genuine and valid.
The Bench observed that if a woman is genuinely kept completely unaware of her partner’s existing marriage, her consent may be vitiated when the truth comes to light.
It added that genuine cases involving betrayal of trust and violation of a woman’s dignity must receive legal protection under Sections 376, 493, 494 and 495 of the IPC.
However, the Court emphasised that whether consent was vitiated must be decided on the basis of facts and evidence in each case, and not merely on allegations or moral assumptions.
In the present case, the material on record did not establish that the woman continued to believe herself to be the man’s legally wedded wife or that the essential ingredients of the offences alleged against him were made out.
The Bench further observed that a relationship turning bitter or acrimonious at a later stage cannot retrospectively convert earlier consensual sexual relations into rape.
Allowing the appeals, the Supreme Court set aside the orders of the Kerala High Court and discharged the man from the criminal proceedings./ LAB/SNG
